PACIFIC PERSPECTIVES: What Do Journalists Really Do?

Los Angeles – (a syndicated column by Tom Plate) It’s uncertain whether Asia will come to entertain many Western journalists that tried harder to understand their region, their ways and their history than Barry Wain, who has died at 69. The former editor of the once Hong Kong-based Asian Wall Street Journal (also deceased) left behind a legacy of a standard of reporting and editing that exemplified professional journalistic norms at their best. And of course we don’t always see that in our journalists, do we?

It must be admitted that even as I fondly wish I were half the journalist that this Australian-born workaholic was, I must also admit that we did not always agree on things. He felt my little book of conversations with Malaysia’s Mahathir Mohamad, the long-running former prime minister, was sinfully short on the corruption issue; and I felt his long and painstakingly detailed book (Malaysian Maverick – do buy it!) was, for all its greatness, sinfully short on the vital Muslim-governance issue.

No matter: Yet journalists are by definition sinful types, in large part because our work forces us to move at blinding speed and we do not have the forever time of the historian.  And so we apologize. But our apologies are somewhat insincere, to be truthful. After all, by the time the historian has harrumphed her or his judgment, the government under study has been long toppled or the civilization left in history’s dustbin or the issue made moot or the world stage well onto the Next Big Thing.

So the best journalism has nothing to apologize for. It goes public at a time when people are actually interested in the event or the issue, and seeks to put it into some kind of economic, cultural or historical context, while knowing that the journalistic game is necessarily a rough history on the run and injuries are bound to occur.

Wain was better at avoiding error than almost anyone, and one wishes his thoughts had been included in a terrific new book, just published, titled ‘My First Trip to China.’  Dozens of contributors, many of them well-known, have had stories and essays reprinted of their accounts more or less at the time, or in retrospect, of the first time they set foot on mainland China. It is a gem of a collection (published by East Slope Publishing Ltd. Hong Kong).

Because many of these tippy-toe experiences occurred four decades ago, China was then present-or-post Mao — but definitely pre-Deng Xiaoping.  The great economic switch away from a pure state capitalism to “socialism with Chinese characteristics” (whatever that may mean) had not yet taken place. The retrospective essays in this book were as if the first astronauts had set foot on Mars without knowing how much frozen water lie underneath waiting warm stimulus.

The list of authors in this book, edited by the redoubtable Kin-ming Liu (now on the staff of the South China Morning Post), reads like a who’s who. But, pardon my bias, I found the best writing — and maybe clearest thinking — coming from the journalistic contributors. One of America’s finest prose stylists and most respected China-watcher (and former dean of the graduate school in journalism at the University of California at Berkeley, which is – by the way– one of our few truly good ones) is Orville Schell. He writes with characteristic elegance and cunning in introducing these 30 essays:

“While so much of the rest of the world had been blurring its boundaries during the early stages of 20th century globalization, here was China, becoming not only terra incognita for much of the world, but also conferring on it an air of mesmerizing impenetrability and unpossessability. Its haughty detachment, fierce dedication to self-reliance and abject refusal to surrender to the outside world’s pressure paradoxically also made it a strangely alluring place … at least, for some of us!”

And you can count me in on that. Compared to every single journalist, academic and businessman contributing to this richly readable and informative collection, I was a very-come-lately to Asia and China, which took me until 1996 to visit. And so my remedial re-education, as it were, included reading the works of the greats like (to mention just a few from this book) Perry Link, Jonathan Mirsky, Frank Ching, Roderick MacFarquhar, Jerome Cohen, Ezra Vogel, Andrew Nathan, James Mann and, well, Barry Wain.

To be sure, for the last phase of his life, Wain luxuriated in the special thinkers’ club known formally as the Institute of Southeast Asian Studies in Singapore. China was not his beat. But his standards of reporting and analysis were as one I solidarity with those of the best journalists in ‘My First Trip to China’. Yes, it’s ironic to be taking notice of what’s good about journalism on the occasion of the death of one of its best. But it’s in the nature of what journalists do that we rarely have time to stop and take a look at ourselves.

On the other hand, there certainly are a lot of pluses in that!

America journalist Tom Plate has been writing about Asia and America since 1996, starting with an op-ed column in The Los Angeles Times that later re-emerged as a syndicated feature. The author of the ‘Giants of Asia’ book series is the Distinguished Scholar of Asian and Pacific Studies at Loyola Marymount University in Los Angeles, where he lives.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.